Selected quotes, by topic, from Irvine’s original sermon notes

[page references are to privately held mss. copies: contact Rev. Deverell for information on access]

On the nature of ultimate reality or God

“A man’s religion is the expression of his ultimate attitude to the universe, the summed up meaning and purport of the whole consciousness of things.” p3
“Ultimate truth may always remain veiled. It is the search for it that makes life worth living.” p9
“Love is measured by service.” p37
“The divine cannot be lost and will not be defeated ultimately. This is the faith that underlies all struggle.” p42


“In sacred books we read how God did speak to holy men in many different ways: But hath the present age no God to seek or is God silent in these latter days.” p110

“Nature is a new book. Science has given us a new cosmology. Natural phenomena are no longer interpreted as the caprice of Deity. We have lost our fear and our sense of mystery.” p132

 

“Yesterday men were governed. Today they are the governors. The religion of that day was similar—Departmental deity. Gift of a master to a slave. Our democratic spirit rebels against this. Democracy must worship a social God.” p133
“God is the nucleus of every religious system.” p147
“God is a spirit and that spirit is none other than the spirit of humanity. This is the God of a Democrat.” p149


“Soul—a self conscious personality. God—the totality of being. This being is variously termed power, force, life, causation, mystery, God. We have a relation to the infinite whether we realize it or not.” p157

“Some say, Why not do without God? I do not believe that we can do without God. We cannot stop thinking about him. The God who will help and needs to be helped must be known.” p198
“The God of the human heart. The human heart says spare the weak.” p199

“The ultimate of existence is a veiled being—shows no special interest in life, death, good or evil. Modern religion has nothing to do with the unknowable absolute. The life force is not God.” p200

On the immanence of God
“The eternal mystery whispers to us the meaning of life and the world through this medium. A still small voice within. Willingness to bear cross.” p42
“There is a lifeward impulse, growing up from within. Utters its challenge to every organ and faculty to help. God without revelation. God that is in the struggle with us. Compels us to find a purpose for living. Led to do that for which people have waited centuries for God to do. God is the friend of man. Courage. Knowledge. Goodness. Love.” p201
“Old Eastern legend: The gods stole from man his destiny. At a loss to know where to hide it. Other side of the earth? Bottom of the Sea? Oldest and wisest—‘let us hide it within man himself; that it the last place in which he would think to look for it.” p208
“When after many years of searching you have discovered the God within what is the effect? You are compelled to love the good the true and the beautiful. But you know that you are not different from other people. You discover the same in them. And you love them.” p209

On the nature of Faith
“A characteristic feeling of our nature leading to a confidence in a value in life. The instructive certainty that life is good. Science in this sense is based on faith.” p8
“Faith has to do with ultimate value” p8
“Prayer is the attitude of the whole man to life. Receptivity. God-Fulness. Real prayer is preparation to receive like sunlight. Or communion or companionship. This prayer is always answered because we give the laws of the higher life an opportunity to operate. It is an attitude of effort. It implies effort, companionship, receptivity.” p122
“God’s presence must be an experience, not an inference. Religion must stand the test of life. We cannot test life by religion.” p168

On the definition of religion
“Religion is an attitude of the whole man—feels—thinks—wills—acts.” p3
“Religion is a personal attitude toward life which, beginning in a feeling of dependence and dissatisfaction, rises to a faith that life contains, somewhere and somehow, an eternal and completely satisfying worth and value centred in an objective reality, conceived as perfect and divine into relation with which the dependent and unsatisfied soul can enter in such a way that the sense of dependence and dissatisfaction is resolved and removed.” p4
“Religion as a system of thought is interdependent with all other systems of thought, within the range of human cognition.” p147
“Religion and morality in their origin are one.” p151
“Religion is the expression of a true natural force, proceeding from our deepest being, operating toward the more perfect adjustment of ourselves to our surroundings, and leading to a life in harmony with the laws of the universe.” p157

On Ethics
“History, Politics, Economy, Social statics and dynamics, the law of wealth, the laws of mutuality, the laws of character and heredity, the laws of population, the laws of crime—these must make the subject matter of our study when we seek to follow out any line of practical duty and morals. It is with these and not with any theological scheme of duty and opinion that our nobler sentiments, and our charitable emotions will have to be reconciled.” p112

On the nature and purpose of humanity
“We need to be preparing for life. Much of our preparation has been for death. Self realization and altruism meet.” p21
“Necessity of laying aside every thing that hinders us from being our best. Every man wants to be the best. 1) Hinderence in our system of political economy 2) In our system of education 3) In our moral standards. It requires co-operative effort to lay aside these encumbrances that stand in the way of the individual and the social whole being their best. We should have a purpose in life that summons up all our energy. We need to live intelligently (consciously.) If we have a life purpose, all embracing and intense, we will change the circumstances which prevent us achieving it.” p22
“The writer recognizes the human effort in the Christian life. Task is colossal. Not a hundred yard dash but a marathon.” p23
“It takes more virtue to come away from our pet vices and vaunted opinions, and to acknowledge failure than is required of those who know no vice and have no opinions.” p107
“We know we are not all what we desire to be. Divine urge within. Dynamic agent of all religious effort. Our nature is to love. This is the verdict of all Religion, of History, and of experience.” p113
“We have an unhealthy tendency in education to extend preference for all our habits, accomplishments, characteristics, and conventions to the exclusion of all others. We set ourselves upon a pinnacle. Condemnation and contempt of others. Affection is thus debased into self-complacency and deceit. Germany is perhaps the best example of this. We are following here. An over confidence arises. Boastful determination to dominate follows.” p128
“The man who is always repeating that human nature does not change would not acknowledge a pre-historic man as his relation. There is nothing permanent in humanity. We are in the continuous process of becoming.” p132
“To thine own self be true … self deception is the unpardonable sin. Instead of using intellect as a guide to right, we use it to give reasons for not doing right. It can be a powerful weapon to defend right, but is equally as effective in defence of wrong when conscience is dead.” p154
“It was mans deepest consciousness that he was not what he desired to be which gave a foothold for the entering of fear.” p163

On Humanism
“Humanity must be supreme in the new civilization. Faith in inherent human goodness. The soul of man is Divine. The soul of humanity takes the place of autocratic power and profit-making. Politics, Social life, Industrialism—all must be humanized. Every institution must have for its aim the well-being of all humanity.” p188
“It is the power of the intellect to guide that distinguishes humanity from the brute.” p155
“Every man that loves humanity and tries to serve with sincerity merits recognition even if mistaken. If our study of martyrs helps us to see this it will not have been in vain.” p139
“All life values are increased by the example of those who have discovered something of its meaning and who had faith in its ultimate reality.” p219
“But what is a man to do if he cannot find work and has no money?” p99
“We are first born to live. 'I came that ye might have life.' One thing that all the world wants, and has it not—Life—Abundant life. The means of life itself is Bread and Butter. These have been degraded by theologians, because they seldom lacked it long enough to learn its fundamental necessity. Nothing to be gained by denying the physical basis of life. Food, clothing and shelter. The Trinity that in Unity make life possible.” p203-204
“Can there be a Rational Religion? Seems to be a contradiction of terms. The function of religion in society seems to be to provide a super-rational sanction for individual conduct leading to a progress which is racial rather than individualistic. Religion is a form of belief which leads to the subordination of the personal interests in favour of the community interest when these are antagonistic and thus leads to the general evolution of the race. Bound by customs as forcible as law.” p237

On the relationship of religion to life
“Religion cannot be isolated from the rest of life and thought.” p1
“Reverence and love for the ethical ideal, and the desire to realize that ideal in life.” p3
“Our type of religion has as much to do with Geography as the colour of our skin. All Gods are human creations. Gods are human explanations of the Universe and life in terms of personality. To feel the utter humanness of all religions will broaden our views, enrich our experience and unite humanity. There is no factor in our separation more potent than religious prejudice.” p111
“Selfishness does not alter its nature by being spiritualised. Christianity must redeem Public life or be scrapped. It must be a practical religion—how to live. The time has come for us to preach as many sermons on public or social crime as on Individual Sin.” p117
“Let us get the idea of cooperation with God. Thanksgiving does not consist in what we say about what we get but what we do with what we get … the best way to thank God: for life, is to live it; for brain is to use it; for friends is to be friends; for love is to love in return.” p160

On the Kingdom of God
“Sad to think that we have ignored for 2000 years the dearest wish of Jesus.” p35
“Conditions of life are direct causes of Sins. Bad Housing. Unemployment. Deep-rooted injustice based on ownership. Ownership is economically unwise and morally wrong.” p35
“The Christian Church cannot make terms with injustice.” p36
“A state of being which will afford to every one an opportunity to be his or her best.” p37
  The solutions are political:
“We must elect our own representatives; We must capture the government; This is an agricultural country: Farmers should dominate; You must unite in political action; You must know what you want; We must have control of our representative;” p44
“Will you join us? By breaking up pernicious combination of party-ism; Putting public business on a business basis; Electing own representatives; Getting the legislation you want; and by voting for a man instead of a machine.” p46
“Every human life and mind is a social product. Individualism has permeated the national life. We have missed our true service by worshipping an unholy trinity of Individualism, Sacredness of property and profits.” p63
“Character is the religious goal. If character be something that grows, we must look to the environment. Are our institutions such as will aid the highest character? The best way to develop character in individuals is to clean out society.” p165
“Kingdom of God historically means social righteousness. Social repentance. End of oppression. Strife. War. Reorganization of society on the ethics of Jesus. Is this impossible? Righteousness = Right relationship.” p184

On the Church
“The church is an organization or association of persons who focus their combined energies in an effort to establish the Kingdom of God on earth.” p37
“Because organized service is most effective, Church must be a force for righteousness.” p38
“The functions of the modern church must be as broad as the expanse of human need.”p40
“The churches have preached jingoism. Asked our men to enlist. I challenge them to be more patriotic. It is an indictment of the strongest possible character against the institution bearing the title Christian, that it has placed human life at a lower value than corporation profits.” p66
“The Church should be prepared to die for her principles, but she is not.” p73
“The church can never build up a morality on empty heads and empty stomachs.” p102
“An unemployed church looking for a job. Let the church be its own notice board. Make it indispensable to the life of the community by service and people will patronize. If not, it ought to go.” p144
“Our practical religious program: Unite people of different opinions upon an ethical and humanitarian ground. No economic system which perpetuates poverty can be ethical or humanitarian. A political system which exists chiefly for its own sake must go.Must take direct action.” p189
“We need to be taught that we are not here to make money, but a life—character. That what the church at her best has stood for, is worthy of our attention yet.” p223
“The need for an all peoples church. The new age. Each age made its own picture of the highest and best and called it God. Our time has come. We must make new bottles for new wine. It requires a great new faith to see the supreme good in a world of so much suffering.” p231
“Lead to the practical work of humanizing civilization. What a power an All peoples church might become. Rev. W. A. Sunday. Hundreds of thousands flock to hear him preach Hell. $60,000 in one collection. This for what is error to us. Have we got nothing worth endeavour and sacrifice?” p234

On Religion, Christianity, and Socialism
“Orthodox Socialism is as much out of date as orthodox religion.” p73
“I am a Christian and a socialist even if they both reject me. Let human happiness or welfare be the basis of our Economic and religious efforts, and it is possible to work together.” p73
“Thus the ruling class by fraud and superstition exploited the hero of history [Jesus]—the friend and champion of the poor.” p77
“Moses the first labour leader.” p78
“Oppression, slavery, humanity—common to all people.” p78
“This great man [Jesus] combined imagination and practical leadership with a passionate religion and stands as one of the first to rebel against slavery.” p79
“Recognized economic crime. Forgave a fallen woman but not a rich young ruler.” p80
“It takes 2/3rds of Canada's natural resources, and the service of all the people to make 23 successful men, yet we are told that their brains took them there. I would like to see them do it again. Tomorrow we shall have but two great classes—the possessors and the dispossessed.” p101
“The church wants to make men moral. The trade unions and farmer organizations are in the front trenches. Social and moral reform leagues are an auxiliary of the Church. There is a lack of cohesion. Each faction is riding its hobby to death like a heap of sand. May someone come with a pot of glue! We have not enough cohesiveness to elect one member to legislature.” pp102-103
“Self realization and socialism meet. We know that the type of individual and social character we want cannot grow in our present environment. No matter what you believe, we are challenged to save the world.” p113
“Are the interests of the individual and that of the social organism necessarily antagonistic?” p236

On Jesus
“Whatever preference we may give Him, we do not limit ourselves to Him. There are many who stand with Jesus in suffering and death.” p24
“We must strive to be Jesus.” p32
“A great soul hampered by limitations. Who sees most suffers most. His agony—shattering of dream—fear for his disciples.” p81
“Because Jesus was God, and God loves every body. God is Love. Love is God. If God is love everyone who loves is God to the extent that he loves.” p92
“Jesus was a great lover because he was a great discerner. He could penetrate through all false covering to the real self.” p93
“Jesus was a wonderful teacher. He knew men. Eye could penetrate to the depths of human nature. Tactful and masterly. Our teachers would be better if they knew men and conditions more and classics and methods less.” p104
“A Christian is a person whose life is guided by the spirit of Jesus life. It is not so much what you believe as what you do. A Christian is a person who makes the same sacrifice as Jesus.” p116
“Chirst is the great Universal Reality in human experience—not only the basis but the very soul of character. Christ is a quality. What do we worship? Is it power? Is it vastness? Is it mystery? No it is infinite love. Gentleness, humility, incredible patience, fathomless pity, all-forgiving mercy, victorious courage, purity, gladness.” p176

On the Bible
“The religious ideals expressed by the explanation of these accounts are not ideals for all time.” p30
“Jesus life is a protest against this antiquated creed.” p32
“Nature is our Bible and all phenomena its content. No book ever has, or ever will contain it all.” p110

On multi-Faith
“Life is the greatest of all arts. He who has learned the art of living is the greatest artist. Why have the masses of mankind followed the Buddha? Confucius? Mohammed? Christ? Because they show the art of living.” p24
“It is regrettable that Jesus has been given the monopoly of the Christ. This mistake is back of all the tragedy of Church history.” p34
“All the high ways of the spiritual life have the same end: [to] meet.” p34

On religion and science
“Religion stands as a fact in human history and consciousness. Science must treat it with the same reverence as any other fact.” p2
“The function of science is not to explain but to describe the wonders of life.” p7
“Science does not try to relate facts of experience to ultimate reality.” p7
“Neither religion or science can claim to be the only way to the truth.” p7
“Faith alone can never lead to Knowledge. We must summon Reason to the aid of Faith.” p9
“Modern invention [is designed] to conquer nature by using her properly. Nature is not a monster to be feared but an ally. This new outlook manifests itself in human character: Materialistic … Utilitarian. Things as instruments for human ends.” p 132
“The passion for truth is nothing less than a dim and partially developed act of worship toward the God of Truth.” p167
“Science can work only on what is supposed to repeat itself, that is to say, on what is withdrawn by hypothesis from the action of real time. Anything that is irreducible and irreversible in the successive movements of a history, eludes science.” p169

On the nature of Heaven, Immortality, and Salvation
“If we might not better seek to make a Heaven for ourselves here on earth.” p10
“If you change your mode of life when you think there is no hereafter you are not fit for it if it were.” p14
“Heaven will become a reality when we cease to try to get into Heaven, and begin to try to get Heaven into us.” p15
“How can there be joy without conflict—or happiness without tears? There is no heaven where there is no struggle.” p15
“The conditions which rob Earth of its Heaven: Premature death; the death roll of industry; the death roll of the battle field; poverty. All can be prevented or eliminated.” p15]
“If the orthodox idea of sin be false, their system of salvation must go with it. Sin is a psychological fact, made possible by natural human limitations, not an accidental historic tragedy. Escaping punishment due to sin. Jesus taken as a substitute. The something you get for nothing is not worth much. Immoral. Highest manhood cries out against it. Must substitute development for Salvation. We have divine potentialities.” p164

On religion and democracy
“Our social and economic structure together with our political life is a reflex of our collective intelligence and Morality.” p99
“A people with a sacred ballot in their hands must be held responsible for corruption in public life, and social and economic injustice so long as they allow them to remain.” p100
“We have created certain conditions that make politicians and individuals as helpless as babes. Our only hope lies in Democracy. We must inaugurate a great collective movement, the soul of which shall be a moral passion for righteousness.” p100
“Moral cowardice is the weakness of this age.” p100
“Money-archy is void of both mind and soul.” p100
“A railroad magnate has more direct power than all the people of Canada. Their strength consists of our weakness.” p102
“The first enemy is partyism. The first step is to break up the combination of party politics.” p103
“Party politics do not represent a healthy difference of opinion [they are] corrupt … and maintain [themselves] by fair or foul means. The ambition is to win. This is the outcome of a patronage system.” p118
“A spirit of unrest needs guidance, not suffocation. This is the great and supreme task of the church, to educate the public consciousness. Its aim: A God-redeemed democracy.” p120
“There was a time when it was dangerous for a man not to have a master. Was liable to pillage at any time and no one would claim the right to defend him.” p148

On progress
“If there is any rational content in the word progress it consists in that degree in which human intelligence has been able to remove obstacles.” p21
t“These are times when great things are being done. Ultra conservatism, politically, socially, economically, and religiously have dammed up the river of progress. It cannot be stopped flowing.” p43

On feminism
“What does war mean to women? We have no official record of this. It is a curious fact that women hold such a small part in the recorded history of the world. Proof that there is no real history of the race. Brute force predominated, men had more force. From history one would think that nothing but man ever lived and all that they ever did was to fight. If I were a woman I would feel the sting of this insult. The real facts cannot be entirely hid. Realize that women in all ages have borne the drudgery, sweat, hunger, and pain in a world's strife and struggle.” pp47-48
“Who ploughed the fields, made clothing, fed the children, protected the home? Who helped to pay the cost of war? Who cared for the wounded? Who replenished the decimated ranks of battle?” p48
“Why do not Women go to War? Some answer that it is not women's work. But what is? Wash, scrub, bake, nurse. Rest on a falsehood. Sex occupation. Vocation knows no sex. Dividing line artificial. Plea for the ulitmate and fundamental equality for the human ego. To be recognized in every sphere of life.” p50
“When women through environment and heredity has developed in similar degree the powers of generalization, initiative, invention, and logical deduction which characterizes man, and when man has evolved those powers of intuition, psychological analyses, spiritual refinement, patience and unselfishness which distinguish women, Then and only then will they become companions.” p52

On war
“Women will make war on War.” p51
“The biological argument for war is false. Look at the monsters of intiquity. They were equipped by nature with 30 ft long armoured heads, 12-14 foot tusks, clawed feet or mouths with 4 rows of teeth. Where are these now? Horses, cows, sheep. Goats; monkeys still survive. Force is a failure everywhere.” p61
“The world is at war because it was better prepared for war than for brotherhood, internationalism, and peace. Capitalism and Militarism are still the twin enemies of labour.” p127

On co-operation
“Victory lies in mutual understanding—that all can get nearer to what they want by co-operation than by strife.” p210
“Brotherhood is the extension of the home spirit into the affairs of life in the broadest and deepest sense. Here we see the ideal state in miniature. The home was our first lesson in living together. Humanity has had in the home a long course of training in the brotherhood spirit. We lost our false notion of superiority. Felt our oneness with that unity. Rejoiced in the sweet influence hallowed by the years. Felt the pull of common responsibility. Learned something of the art of harmony. Spirit spread from family to group to clan to nation, outgrowing these forms. Need to be baptised by the spirit.” p211
“Better farming. Better Business. Better living. (So as to equal city life.) This is the meaning and the aim of the cooperative movement.” p226
“What cooperation is? An organization for joint trading, originating among the weak, and conducted always in an unselfish spirit on such terms that all who are prepared to assume the duties of membership may share in its rewards in proportion to the degree in which they make use of the association.” p227

On the nature of the Criminal
  Irvine describes the stereotype of the criminal and society’s tendency to hold the criminal entirely responsible for his acts. pp 67f
“History of criminology shows imprisonment the surest way to establish offenders in crime.” p68
  He calls for a system that provides dignity, education, and rehabilitation. He proposed a bill to eliminate capital punishment. p69
“The criminal is as much an effect as a cause. Society has been the chief unconscious cause of crime. A society which maintains slums, and over-crowding poverty due to mal-distribution of wealth. Unemployment, starvation wages, licensed saloons, brothels, ignorance—has no right to punish any on. Our first duty is to remove the cause.” p172
“No man chooses crime for its own sake. Seeking more abundant life. Self-expression. Seeks it in wrong way. Our prisons are the greatest enemy to society. Shame is written all over their walls. Rob men of dignity and honour. Solitude and unkindness breeds crime.” p173